Provo City Homepage

Navigation
  • 2004 State of the City

  • Online Utility Payments


    Report Errors

    Please help us improve this web site by sending suggestions and reporting broken links or other problems to the webmaster



     
      Quick Links:
  • Home
  • Employment Opportunities
  • Contacts
  •  
    Printer friendly page Printer friendly page
    Provo City » Provo City Government » Provo Mayor's Office » Public Information » Mayor's Speeches
    Mayor's Speeches

    Mayor Lewis K. Billings Remarks
    Patriot’s Day Services
    Provo Memorial Park
    September 10, 2005

    Provo City, State of the City
    Administrative Report and Partial List of Key Accomplishments
    For the Twelve Month Period ending December 31, 2005

    Provo City State of the City Administrative Report and Partial List of Key Accomplishments
    For the Twelve Month Period ending December 31, 2004

    Benefits of a Community Broadband Network
    Speech before the American Public Power Association
    Community Broadband Conference

    Mayor’s 2004-2005 Budget Message

    Provo City State of the City Administrative Report and Partial List of Key Accomplishments
    For the Twelve Month Period ending December 31, 2003

    Provo City State of the City
    Administrative Report and Partial List of Accomplishments
    For the Twelve Month Period ending December 31, 2002

    Mayor’s Award of Excellence

    Provo City Administrative Report and Partial List of Accomplishments
    December 31, 2000

     

    Mayor Lewis K. Billings Remarks
    Patriot’s Day Services
    Provo Memorial Park

    September 10, 2005

    "All Americans Can and Should Be Patriots"

    Good morning. On this special and even sacred morning, we pause as a community and as a Nation to remember.

    First, we remember the hundreds of thousands of Americans who have left the comfort of family and home to travel to distant lands in defense of freedom. We are especially mindful of those who have made the ultimate patriotic gift. May God bless their souls.

    This morning, we pause to remember the thousands of typically working Americans who lost their lives that dark September 11th day in New York, Washington D. C. and in a Pennsylvania field. We acknowledge the fact that their sacrifice served to promote a greater feeling of "Patriotism" and "Love of Country" than any other act in the last 50 years. Those who died that morning are sorely missed.

    This morning we are very aware of the thousands who lost their lives as a result of the impact of Hurricane Katrina. We are inspired by the many who have opened their hearts, their wallets, and even their homes to help a fellow American in need. We pray for appropriate and prompt action on the part of government officials and hope that those who are now willing to go to work to rebuild their own lives will have every appropriate vestige of support from a caring sympathetic Nation.

    As we have watched emergency responders deal with the aftermath of Katrina, we are reminded of the important work performed on our own city by the men and women of our Police, Fire, and other city departments. We are greatly blessed as a result of their hard work and dedication.

    The dictionary defines Patriot as "One who loves his country and who zealously supports its authority and interests." In recent years, we have truly witnessed numerous acts of selfless service, courage, and a host of other actions that qualify many as true American Patriots. As Americans, we all can and should be Patriots!

    Perhaps our Patriot’s label won’t be won on a battle field, but in a classroom, or in a Scout Troop, at City Hall, or some other similar important place. On this day that is special among days, we need to open our hearts and our minds and ponder the great privilege we have as Americans and to consider what we can do to be more effective Patriots.

    Now finally, with deep gratitude, we must always remember and be grateful to all of our military veterans. No matter the conflict in which you served, no matter the role you played, no one is more deserving and worthy of the title "Patriot" than the men and women who have served the people of this Nation in the Armed Forces and to their families.

    May God speak peace to the souls of those who mourn great losses this day. May God continue to bless this great Nation, even a nation of Patriots.

     

    Speech before the

    American Public Power Association

    Community Broadband Conference

    San Francisco, CA

    Monday, October 11, 2004

    By Mayor Lewis K. Billings

     

    Benefits of a Community Broadband Network

     

     

    After joke and introduction:

     

    In this rapidly changing world we live in, I’ve found you can’t believe everything people say. Consider, for example, the accuracy of the following statements, which no doubt sounded pretty good when they were uttered:

    “This telephone has too many shortcomings to be seriously considered as a means of communication.  The device is inherently of no value to us.”  (Western Union Internal Memo, 1876)

    “The wireless music box has no imaginable commercial value.  Who would pay for a message sent to nobody in particular?” (Response of Associates of David Sarnoff, when invited to invest in radio)

    “I think there is a market for about five computers.”  (Thomas Watson, Sr. Founder of IBM, 1943)

    “There is no reason anyone would want a computer in their home.” (Ken Olsen, President and Founder of Digital Equipment Corp., 1977)

    “Fax machines; who needs one?  This is a technology that will never catch on.  Let’s buy one for the entire city and put it in the Recorder’s Office and let that suffice.  When fax machines go out of style, we will be glad we didn’t waste our money on them.” (Former Mayor of Provo City)

    “Fiber optic’s capabilities are way more than what most consumers need in their homes. Why provide a Rolls Royce when a Chevrolet will do?” (Utah President of Qwest, 2003)

    The last quote is particularly appropriate for my assigned topic today. It was spoken during a legislative debate over iProvo, our city’s project to provide a community broadband network connecting potentially every home and business in Provo. In any visionary undertaking, in any effort to step out of the crowd and try something new, there will always be naysayers and critics. This is particularly true of those of us in the public sector who embrace advanced technologies and who want to make these capabilities available to our citizens.

    One of our daily newspapers in Utah editorialized against iProvo, saying high-tech projects like ours “should be left to the dreamers.” I admit it. We’re dreamers – big dreamers. But I believe that big dreamers built this country. Big dreamers built our communities. Big dreamers sent men to the moon. With iProvo, we’re dreamers, but we’ re also doers – very practical doers. We’re building the infrastructure of the future and, in the process, facilitating commerce and enabling entirely new ways of doing business.

    Please allow me to quickly share the Provo Story.  Our population is approximately 113,000. We are located high in the Rocky Mountains, bordered by Utah Lake on one side and mountains rising as high as 14,000 feet on the other. Robert Redford’s Sundance ski resort is located in Provo Canyon 20 minutes away. Provo is the county seat and home of Brigham Young University, one of the largest private universities in the country with some 30,000 students.  Provo is the birthplace and/or home of many innovative businesses; such as, WordPerfect, Novell, NuSkin, Morinda, Donny Osmond, Steven R. Covey, and numerous others.

    Provo is the largest public power city in the state. Provo City Power has existed since 1940. Its beginning was very controversial, just like our broadband project is today, but it has been very popular with our citizens for nearly 65 years. It has been steady and responsive, providing reliable customer service and stable rates.

    When I ran for mayor, one of my platform planks was that I would seek to use technology to benefit the lives of our residents.  After the election, I set out to do just that.  It became clear that we needed a fiber optic network to control traffic lights and traffic cameras, to connect our city facilities, to enhance our public safety capabilities, to accomplish electrical SCADA control, and to provide other municipal services.

    At the time, five private sector companies had franchise agreements in place to provide fiber connectivity, but none could or would provide what we needed. It seemed that the franchisees were mostly interested in simply creaming off the biggest and best customers for fiber connectivity.

    Let me assure you that I am a champion of the private sector. I came out of the private sector.  My background is business. I feel strongly that government should not do what the private sector can and will do.  But we quickly learned that the private sector was not going to step up in our city, so we turned our attention toward meeting our own needs. As we built a backbone and began to develop and deploy internal applications, others, including businesses and residents, began to express similar needs for connectivity to a really big pipe.

    At that point, we began to seriously investigate and explore the feasibility of a fiber-to-the-premises community broadband network. We went through a long and deliberative process; including, thorough study by a special task force of community leaders, numerous public hearings, city council debates and scrutiny, and a great deal of staff work.

    When it became apparent we were getting serious about this, the two very large incumbent telecommunications providers went ballistic. One hired a PR firm and a telemarketing company to make calls to citizens. They also placed full-page ads and ultimately hired people to picket City Hall. It was a bruising fight.  My favorite picket sign had a piece of telephone wire taped to it and read that I and one of my key staff members were, “a Twisted Pair.”

    The efforts of the large incumbents eventually backfired. For example, at one meeting they filled City Hall with people who had received the telemarketing phone calls and had become concerned as a result. But as these citizens listened to what was really being proposed, they became angry that our proposal had been so grossly misrepresented. “What you are doing is completely different than what they said you were doing,” said many in at tendance.

    When they couldn’t stop us at the local level two years ago, our large corporate friends turned their focus to the State Legislature. They proved to be very powerful, thanks, in part, to the many contributions they had made to state legislative races over the years.

    At first, we were shut out of closed meetings where proposed legislation affecting us was discussed.  Eventually, the sponsor of the legislation was convinced he should meet with us and, ultimately, made numerous, significant compromises. As initially proposed, the legislation would have prevented us from proceeding with the project. As finally passed, it allowed us to proceed, but required that we adopt a wholesale, open network model, rather than offer retail services ourselves.

    This would not be the only challenge to our project. Another legislative effort was launched in the State Senate last year.  This time the Senate President personally promoted the highly damaging legislation. At the Capitol, it was common to hear our opponents say things such as, “The Mayor doesn’t need more fiber, he has plenty already in his city.” Or, “We are expanding DSL in Provo. The Mayor just needs to be a little more patient.” Legislators became confused, and it truly seemed as though our opponents had adopted the philosophy: “If you can’t convince, simply confuse.” With the invaluable assistance of many others, we were able to finally prevail and defeat this legislation. About two months ago, we became fully funded and launched the citywide build-out of our fiber-to-the-premises project.

    Wanting to be sure the technology was proven, we built a 300-home test area two years ago.  While we had some problems with our telephone switch provider, the technology worked, and the services offered were popular.

    Our network is a full-blown fiber-to-the-premises network. It is Ethernet based, using (TCP/IP) Transmission Control Protocol/Internet Protocol. It is an active network (electronics controlling the signal from start to finish) rather than passive, where optical splitters are used to divide the signal. In our opinion, this provides better control and bandwidth. Our backbone is a gigabit backbone (1,000 megabit).

    I believe building our community broadband network is one of the most important things I will accomplish during my tenure as mayor.  I’m convinced of this because ultra-broadband connectivity will encourage and enable exciting new and innovative technology applications that will bolster our economy and change the way we work, learn, and play.

    As mentioned previously, the president of one of Utah’s largest telecommunications companies recently told the media, “Why provide a Rolls Royce, when a Chevrolet will do?”  A more apt analogy would have been, “Why provide a gazelle, when a snail will do?”

    When it comes to telecommunications services, our businesses and residents want a gazelle.  They are tired of the World Wide Wait.  They want fully interactive, full-motion video. They want advanced telemedicine services.  They want fully interactive distance learning. They want state-of-the-art video-conferencing. They want to instantaneously transfer large graphic files and photos.  They want web-based home security, multi-media email, and HDTV. They want to see and chat with an elderly parent or grandparent via a video phone. They want Voice-over Internet Protocol (VoIP) telephony that really works. They want to watch their children’s school productions and sports activities on a community network. Our city wants remote meter reading. We want traffic light synchronization. We want our dispatchers to use street cameras for more effective accident oversight and response.  We want our Police and Fire stations to have state-of-the-art telecommunication functionality.  Yes, it could be said that we want the gazelle, even the Rolls Royce -- especially since we project it can be offered at a Chevy price.

    All the applications I just mentioned are available here and now. We understand them and can readily deploy them with a community broadband network. But I believe the real promise of what we are doing lies in the applications that we DON’T understand today, things I can’t even comprehend that will be enabled by the immense capacity of our network. The real promise of this technology is in the applications still in the minds of young, smart, innovative entrepreneurs who will design ways to employ it that I can ’t begin to fathom. I absolutely believe the network will spawn innovation and creativity in many kinds of businesses, educators, hospitals, doctors, and even, believe it or not, government.

    Let me provide a quick demonstration of the bandwidth I am referring to which will instigate this innovation. Our detractors are fond of saying that DSL or cable modem capabilities are all we need. What is this big pipe we’re talking about? How does one big pipe differ from another?

    (Rope band-width demonstration)

    This kind of bandwidth changes everything. There’s an old saying that we always overestimate the impact of technology in the short run, but underestimate it in the long run. That’s very true. The spectacular build-up and then bursting of the dot-com balloon a few years ago did nothing to invalidate the underlying technologies that have continued to be developed unabated. Today, many Internet businesses are making profits and doing extremely well, while businesses or government entities without a robust Internet strategy are in serious trouble. Ultra-broadband capabilities in every home and business will accelerate the transformation of whole industries. Every web site will become a potential full-motion, interactive video broadcast channel and every computer a potential interactive receiver of millions of these broadcast web sites. What this will enable in business, education, medicine, and the public sector is mind-boggling.

    With ultra-broadband, everything becomes instantaneous. The vision of the network becoming the computer is realized. The need for desktop software updates is eliminated. The hope for a very inexpensive network computer appliance becomes a reality. Everything is hosted out on the network. We subscribe to storage, applications, and software on the network with which we interact as instantly as if it were on our desktop hard drive. Security, privacy, and redundancy are vastly improved over what is possible individually.

    Interactive distance learning finally becomes a low-cost reality. The biggest market in the world is China. How are we going to teach our high school students Chinese instead of French? In Utah we have a few teachers who can teach Chinese. With our network, they can teach students all over the state. With our network, all lessons and multi-media material can be housed on a central server, instantly available to any classroom in the state. No more sending videos or DVDs out to schools. Telemedicine comes out of the dark ages. High-quality medical services become available in rural areas.  Applications for business are limited only by the imagination of entrepreneurs. Full-motion video to and from any desktop changes everything. Political campaigns become dramatically different. A candidate could hold five remote town-hall meetings in one day instead of traveling from town to town.  

    Local governments have always been facilitators and partners with private businesses and free enterprise.  We have always had the role of providing infrastructure that would be too difficult or too expensive for a private firm to provide alone. Municipalities enable robust competition in the private sector by providing basic services like police and fire protection, by installing and maintaining essential infrastructure like roads, bridges, water systems and airports.  Today, a new basic infrastructure is crucial to our success.  FCC Chairman Michael Copps put it this way, “Broadband networks will be as critical to this new century as roads, canals, and railroads were to the 19th Century and as the Interstate Highway System and basic telephone networks were to the 20th Century.”

    Businesses simply won’t locate in communities where these services are not available and fully functioning. Job creation and economic growth are absolutely dependent on these basic services and infrastructure capacity.

    Consider an example I will refer to as “A Tale of Two Cities.” Cedar Falls and Waterloo are adjacent cities in Iowa, literally across the street from one another. They have similar tax structures, educational levels, and economic bases. Yet, in the last half-dozen years, Cedar Falls has seen significant growth in business relocations, construction, and tax base, while Waterloo’s economic growth has been stagnant. What made the difference?  Most observers attribute it to a giant step Cedar Falls took in 1996 when it made fiber optic connections available to every home and business in the city.  Since then, annual new construction in Cedar Falls has tripled from $32 million in 1996 to $101 million in 2002. Waterloo has remained flat, hitting an eight-year low in 2002 at $53 million.  Cedar Falls’ business club now hosts 125 businesses, while Waterloo’s has only 10.  Waterloo’s mayor told the local newspaper, “Fiber optics is the key to Waterloo’s future growth. In order for Waterloo and its businesses to move into the 21st Century, we need fiber optic capability. . . I believe it has hurt us economically not to be able to provide fiber optics to businesses locating in our city.”

    In Provo, we believe it is conservative to build the economic base of the community instead of raising taxes.  Telecom companies have said it is too expensive to run fiber to every home and business. Their return-on-investment would not be quick enough.  And we understand that. No single company could justify such an investment.  But cities are suited to install this infrastructure. The investment can be repaid with favorable interest rates over 10 to 20 years, a far longer repayment period than a private company could justify

    As stated, I personally believe that government should not do what the private sector can and will do.  Although the incumbent providers will say they have and will step up to the plate, it is just not financially realistic or feasible for them to do so.

    Please allow me to close with a few e-mail comments from Provo residents.

    Michael Stephenson:  “I’m lucky. I’ve participated in the iProvo test. I have only good to say about this initiative. I own a small software consulting firm. I write software for engineers. I contract with one of the country’s premier national laboratories and collaborate with co-workers across the country. All of this wouldn’t be possible without high-speed Internet access. I think it’s an appropriate governmental function to provide the infrastructure that promotes economic growth. In years to come, it will prove to be a decision that generates economic growth for Provo.” 

    Heather and Michael Graham: “We believe iProvo will be an extremely important asset to our community. Our time is valuable! Working with slow Internet and limited resources costs us both time and money in our small business and as a family. Please support iProvo and help give us, as consumers, a better choice.”

    Stin Hansen: “My business depends on high-speed Internet access, and, as a mother of four working from home, the ability to have a home office is very important to me. The prospect of having more services, improved performance, and hopefully more competitive prices is very appealing to me.”

    Derek Shumway: “My wife and I have been iProvo users since its inception. What really sets iProvo apart is the Internet service. I fully expected, as we moved into the 21st Century, someone would open the information floodgates and let me get out of my go-cart and traverse the Internet in a race car. iProvo did. iProvo is hands-down the best ISP available. I have never had anyone use my computer and not say, ‘Wow! And you pay how much for this?’”

    Gordon and Cathy Thomas: “We can’t think of a moment in recent history in Provo when such a great idea as iProvo came along and won the support of city government. Thank you for your wise and caring leadership. Don ’t be scared off by the well-heeled and selfish bullies who are running expensive TV ads opposing this superb idea.”

     I could go on and on.

    It is our goal, short and simple, to position our city for the future. I believe we have three choices. We can follow and die. We can stay even and survive. Or, we can lead and prosper. We’ve decided we want our city to prosper.

    Thank you, and good luck with your community broadband projects.

                                                                                                                                                        

    (Lewis K. Billings was elected Mayor of Provo, Utah in November 1997 and 2001.  For more information regarding Provo City and/or the iProvo Telecommunications Project, contact Mary DeLaMare-Schaefer at email: mdschaef@provo.gov or telephone: (801) 852-6867.)

     

    May 4, 2004

     

     

    Provo City Municipal Council
    c/o David Knecht, Chair
    351 West Center Street
    Provo, Utah 84601

    Re: Proposed Budget for Fiscal 2005

    Ladies and Gentlemen:

     

         We are pleased to transmit herewith, our proposed budget for Fiscal 2005 (for the period of July 1, 2004 to June 30, 2005).

         As you begin your review of this budget, you will quickly realize that this is a very tight and financially challenging year. Not unlike many of the budgets of recent past, we are faced with the need to be very careful and selective in how we will spend the resources we have. While very limited, we believe our resources are sufficient to meet the ongoing needs of our city and its residents.

         Please consider the following key points and highlights:

         Balanced Budget - This budget represents a "balanced budget" in that the revenues needed to cover the proposed ongoing expenditures will be generated during the Fiscal 2005 period, and will not require onetime subsidy from other funding sources.

         Slow Economy - All sectors of business and government continue to feel the impact of a slow economy (during January, February, and March we have seen a slight positive increase).  Most of our key revenue sources continue to be significantly below what historical averages suggest they should be (e.g. sales tax revenues are down eight to ten percent and property tax revenues are down eight percent).

           Water Fund  - We remain committed to competitive user fees and highly dependable utility and other city services.  The current level of funding available in the Water Fund, based on current revenues, will be insufficient to cover the costs associated with operating that utility on a balanced budget basis and still have the money necessary to develop new wells throughout the city.  This budget proposes a 6.5 percent increase in our water rates to balance that fund and to allow for further well development (see comparative graph of fees before proposed rate increase  green).

         Sanitation "Triple Play" - Provo residents now have several options to reduce their monthly sanitation bill.  While this budget proposes a $.50 per month per black can increase as was discussed one year ago, we are pleased to recommend with this budget new incentives for residents who sign up for what we propose to call "TriplePlay."  We look forward to talking further about these options in the coming weeks.

         Irrigation System  - Given the need to foster good water conservation practices and the fact that open ditch distribution of irrigation water has come under significant scrutiny in recent years, we need to rethink our practice and policy regarding our city irrigation utility.   In the 1960's there were more than 2,000 subscribers to our Provo City irrigation utility. Today, there are less than 150 users and our annual cost per user is nearly $1,000.00. However, the average irrigation customer pays only $20.00 per year leaving the taxpayers of Provo to pick up the difference in costs associated with the operation of this historically important utility.  In this budget, we propose a final "buyout" of those customers who continue to use this service in an effort to assist them in making other appropriate arrangements for more efficient water delivery to their property.  We believe there are reasonable and workable options for all current users (see proposed Strategic Plan for Provo City Irrigation blue).

         Business Licensing - Utah law allows municipalities to charge a business license fee that is commensurate with the real costs associated with the administration of that licensing program. This is another area where our fees have been too low and thus have not covered the associated costs. In this budget, we propose a restructuring of those fees to be more in line and keeping with the real costs associated therewith (see comparative graph of fees after proposed rate increase yellow).

         Emergency Response Fund  - The Utah State Legislature passed legislation that will take away a portion of the funding in our E911 Emergency Response fund. Rather than raising these fees, the Legislature gave us the authority to raise these fees in an amount sufficient to cover most of what was redirected, but we are left to raise the fees or to do without.  Given the tightness of this budget, we are left with little choice but to propose an offsetting $.12 per month increase in our Emergency Response Fund charge to replace those monies impacted by legislative action.

         No Other Fee Increases - Other than those listed above, no other fee increases are proposed.

         Electricity/WAPA Issues - Our electrical utility rates have remained very competitive and stable in a widely changing marketplace. After several years of drought, our WAPA (Glen Canyon Dam) resource has become a much more expensive source of power and potentially could become even more so depending on what "Mother Nature" decides to do. In cooperation with our partner UMPA, we have sought to forecast and plan for almost every eventuality. Should the current drought conditions continue in the pattern of the recent past, we may be forced to come back and revisit this important issue.

         "Onestop Shop" - We feel there is a tremendous opportunity to significantly improve our efficiency in working with developers and providing oversight for new development. In this budget, we propose the creation of a "Onestop Shop" approach to development interface and oversight.  Given there are no new monies available, we propose to fund this new feature through the use of existing monies, and through limited staff reassignment.  "Onestop Shop" will not only make us more efficient and responsive to those involved with development projects within Provo, but will allow us to be more effective in our oversight of such projects.

         Community Development Remodel  - Given the significant expansion of the Zoning and Nuisance Enforcement team in Community Development and the proposed addition of the "Onestop Shop," there is pressing need to do something to more effectively and efficiently house the operations of this department.  This budget proposes a onetime appropriation of approximately $125,000.00 to go with monies previously appropriated, in an effort to address the physical facility needs of several city departments including Community Development.

         Telecommunications Project - Included with this budget for the first time is our proposed spending plan for the first full year of construction and operation of our new Provo Telecommunications utility known by many as iProvo.

         Capital Improvements -  It is vital that we continue to invest in our infrastructure and utility delivery systems so we don’t fall behind in maintenance and other related capital expenditure. While we would always like to be able to fund more in every capital category, we are pleased to report that this budget proposes total Capital Improvement spending in the amount of $34,987,004.00 (including $19,533,519.00 for telecommunications project construction).

         Managing Overtime - In our analysis, it is clear that we exceed the normal requirements of the Federal Fair Labor and Standards Act and that of most other municipalities when it comes to our policy regulating overtime pay.  Federal Law requires an employer to pay overtime on all hours that an employee works.  The key word is "works."  Our long standing policy has counted all leave time, including sick leave, vacation time, compensatory time, etc. as hours worked and then paid.  We now propose to realign our policy with one that is more generally consistent with other municipal entities.

         Standing Hiring Review Committee - We continue to review every vacancy that occurs in the City to determine if there are yet further opportunities to restructure and/or reduce costs associated with our many operations.  This review is currently performed by a committee comprised of the Chief Administrative Officer, Human Resources Director and City Treasurer. The committee regularly reports its findings and recommendations directly to the Mayor.

         Employees  - Our employees continue to be our most valuable asset and resource as we seek to effectively serve the residents of Provo. It is important that they know of our interest in their well being and that we do all that we reasonably can to express our confidence in their work and service.

         No Layoffs - This budget does not propose the layoff of any full time employee.

         Merit and Step Increases - In this budget we have fully funded all merit and step increases that will apply during the coming Fiscal year.

         Sick Leave Buyback - We propose the full funding necessary for the sick leave buyback incentive we have traditionally offered our employees.

         Bonus - While no monies have or will be budgeted for a bonus, we propose a continuation of the practice wherein we share 50 percent of all monies saved, due to better than budget performance and cost savings management practices, with our city employees. As is standard practice, such bonus distributions are not made until we have received audited numbers from our independent auditors and received the approval of the Municipal Council.

         Healthcare Costs - The costs associated with healthcare continue to rise.  Provo City employees enjoy very high quality and comprehensive health insurance benefits. Employees who select the CORE plan currently receive $100.00 per month in their HRA/Benecard flexible spending allowance account. In Fiscal 2003, we had to reduce this amount by $20.00 per month, but were able to restore it back to $100.00 per month in the current year.  This budget proposes a similar $25.00 reduction to this allowance effective January 1, 2005.

         COLA - This budget proposes a one percent cost of living increase for all city employees effective January 1, 2005.

         In summary, this letter is not intended to be a complete overview of all that is included within the accompanying budget.  There is a significant amount of detail and information we will need to convey before you will fully know all that we are proposing.

         As you review and consider this budget, we would welcome the opportunity to be responsive to your questions and comments. Please feel free to visit with any of our City Department Heads, Budget Team, Chief Administrative Officer and/or myself. We are grateful for the time you have already committed for such discussion and exchange.

         Thank you for your dedication and interest in this very important process.

     

    Sincerely,

    PROVO CITY MAYOR’S OFFICE

    Lewis K. Billings

                                                               Mayor

    STRATEGIC PLAN
    for Provo City Irrigation System

    Background

    As much of Provo City has transitioned over the years from agricultural uses to urban land uses, the total number of water users on the City irrigation system has dropped. In the 1960’s, there were more than 2000 users in the system, irrigating approximately 2500 acres of ground. By the mid 1980's, that number of users was down to about 1200 users. At the start of the 1998 irrigation season, the number of users was down to about 450. This year, there will be approximately 150 users, irrigating less than lOO acres of ground. Most all of this reduction in use has been voluntary withdrawal from the system due to the development/redevelopment of property , or the desire to no longer utilize surface irrigation. A small amount (less than 120 users) of the reduction has been involuntary due to construction projects and/or deterioration of the system.

    Issues

    Two major concerns exist with continued operation of the City irrigation system: economics and water conservation.

    Most of the costs associated with operating and maintaining the City irrigation system are relatively fixed. While the total 0 & M costs for the City irrigation system have remained fairly level, the average cost per user has risen dramatically. While in the 1960’s, the average annual cost per user was less than $50, this year it will be close to $1,000 /user. The average annual revenue per user is approximately $20. The rest of the costs are being subsidized by the other City residents and businesses, which do not benefit directly from the City irrigation system. The question has been raised as to the equity and justification of continuing a subsidy of this magnitude, which directly benefits such a small percentage of City residents (less than 1%).

    During a full irrigation season, approximately 10,000 acre feet of water are diverted out of Provo River for irrigation purposes. That means lOO feet of water is diverted for each acre of ground irrigated. Most of that water (greater than  90 %) is lost or "wasted" through percolation into the ground along ditches and canals and/or through tail water discharged back to Provo River or Provo Bay. In these days of greater sensitivity to the need for water conservation; the continued operation of such a grossly inefficient use of water is increasingly difficult to defend.

    Future

    Given these significant concerns, and while recognizing the importance of continued irrigation service to some of the larger users on the system; following is the planned course of action over the next few years relative to the City irrigation system:

    2004

    • Irrigation service will be offered to remaining active users on the system.
    • A voluntary "buyout" (similar to last year) will also be offered one last time.
    • A significant irrigation rate increase will be proposed (in the budget submitted this year, to be effective in 2005) to apply to the remaining users on the system. Even a significant rate increase still would not cover the costs of continuing to operate and maintain the system.
    • Complete audit of how much land is being irrigated by remaining users.

    2005

    • Irrigation ditches with only a few users and/or only small "garden" users will begin to be phased out.
    • An evaluation will made to determine the possibility of combining all remaining users into one diversion out of the Provo River thus reducing the total amount of water diverted, reducing the O & M costs of the system, and improving the water efficiency of the system.
    • Adopted irrigation rate increase will go into effect for remaining users.
    • An evaluation will be made to determine the feasibility of converting some large users to a shallow ground water well system for irrigation water .

    2006

    • Additional irrigation ditches with only a few users, serving only small to moderate areas, and/or which are isolated will be phased out.
    • A determination will be made as to the most cost effective method, if any, to continue serving the remaining large irrigation users.

    Provo City remains committed to providing dependable services that are competitively priced, the reasonable fees for which cover the costs associated with the service provided. Given the changing nature of the circumstances today. it is no longer possible to meet these objectives in the irrigation utility .Your feedback and comments are welcome.

    Copies of the 2004-2005 proposed budget are available in the Mayor’s Office and Budget Office located at 351 West Center and at the Provo Library located at 550 N. University Ave.

    Provo City
    Administrative Report
    and Partial List of
     Key Accomplishments

    For the Twelve Month Period
    Ending December 31, 2003

    f

     “Provo is a remarkable community comprised of people who value faith, family, and freedom.  Thanks to the dedication and cooperative hard work of City employees and Provo residents, our community is one of the safest cities of our size in America. We enjoy clean streets, dependable and reasonably priced utilities, natural mountain beauty, and a host of other benefits that create a wonderful and unique quality of life.”

    -Mayor Lewis K. Billings-

     

    Presented by Mayor Lewis K. Billings
    In conjunction with the State of the City Report
    January 6, 2004

    Partial List of Key Accomplishments for 2003
    by Department and/or Division
    Presented by Mayor Lewis K. Billings
    January 6, 2004

     

    Community Development:

    • New Rental Dwelling Licensing Program - An entirely new application process for the rental dwelling licensing program was created. Six new employees were hired to assist in the administration of the program and public training and information meetings were held.
    • Formation of Neighborhood Alliance - An alliance was formed with a resident committee from the Franklin Neighborhood to perform concentrated zoning enforcement during a nine-month period which resulted in over 100 enforcement cases.
    • Continuation of Enforcement and Research - There have been 607 zone verifications and 774 enforcement cases completed to-date.  There are 2,725 rental dwelling license properties currently under review.
    • Efforts with Redevelopment Agency - Inspections have been performed and construction advice given for the remodel and sale of homes as part of the Redevelopment Agency’s neighborhood revitalization projects.
    • General Plan Five-year Update - Three public open houses and seven separate public hearings with the Planning Commission were held as part of a major review of the General Plan.

    Economic Development & Redevelopment:

    • Construction of Wells Fargo - A deal with the developer, including the financing of a 523-car parking structure, was successfully negotiated; the remaining parcels of real estate were acquired; the site was demolished and prepared; and construction is underway.
    • Construction of Home Depot - Site preparation and infrastructure costs were financed, making this project possible.
    • Progress of Ironton Project - An agreement with HUD to draw down 108 Loan funds was entered into and $3,500,000 was transferred to City accounts. A $180,000 reimbursement from an EDA Special Purchase Grant was received by Phase One Engineering.  An Army Corps of Engineers 404 permit was applied for and received for construction of the spine road and utility improvements at Ironton.  A land exchange with BYU was completed for property at Ironton.
    • Activity in 80-20 Program - 47 new homeowners in the Pioneer Neighborhoods were provided with 80-20 down payment assistance for a total of 118 since this program was initiated.
    • Activity in Home Ownership Programs - Site acquisition of the Franklin Commons for NHS  was financed (17 new owner-occupied homes). Thirty-eight new homeowners citywide were provided with down payment/closing cost assistance. Two additional homes for purchase/rehabilitation/resale were acquired.  Rehabilitation was completed or is underway on five purchase/rehabilitation/resale homes. The Herring house was demolished and neighborhood consultations conducted regarding future use of the site.  Efforts of the Provo City/Franklin Neighborhood Alliance were joined to determine the direction of continued activities in the Franklin Neighborhood.  Rehabilitation of one NHS purchase/rehabilitation/resale was financed. Purchase by Provo Housing Authority of a six-plex and a duplex for special needs housing was financed.  An ad hoc committee of neighborhood revitalization agencies was joined in a study of how to improve interagency coordination and effectiveness (CNRCC).
    • Progress on Other Central City Projects - Expansion of the Center for Women and Children in Crisis was financed. The site at approximately 1030 West Center Street was purchased and cleared. The Economic Development Initiatives (EDI) Grant to address home ownership in the Pioneer Neighborhoods was successfully lobbied for.
    • New Kuhni Rendering Plant - Three draw downs on the State IFA funding for the new Kuhni rendering plant in Juab County were facilitated. The plant is under construction and on schedule for a July 2004 start up.
    • Business Retention Efforts - Management team business visits to top sales tax revenue producers and downtown businesses were facilitated. (Booklets were produced for each of the 108 business visits.) Stabilization efforts commenced for the Shops at Riverwoods. The process to establish an incubator program was initiated. The downtown and citywide street banner policy was modified.
    • Business Liaison Activities - The sale of new taxis to Mr. Taylor to upgrade a local taxi service was completed.  Atchafalaya was assisted in their efforts to obtain a permit for an outdoor café. The Business Resource Guide was developed jointly with the Finance Department.  (Information was gathered from various departments and compiled into a brochure for local businesses to answer frequently-asked questions, similar to the Citizen’s Reference Guide.)
    • Development of the City’s Web Site - The presence of Provo City on the web was maintained and expanded with the following web sites: Current Issues, Economic Development Department, Engineering, Public Works Department, Arts Council, Mayor’s Office, Police Department, Redevelopment Agency, Sister Cities, Provo Foundation, Emergency Management, Winterfest/First Night.  An interactive virtual tour of Provo was developed and is accessed from www.provo.org/tour
    • NHS Efforts - Staff member Julie Beck served as the chair of the Housing Development Committee for NHS, meeting twice a month to plan the Franklin Commons project. NHS is currently constructing the first three homes in this 17-home development.
    • Sister City Activities - A citizen Sister City committee was established. The Timpview High School Meissen Educational Exchange Program was supported through a City reception and awards presentation. Letters and small gifts were provided to be delivered to Meissen.  NuSkin executives were scheduled to represent Provo City at the 2003 Nanning International Folk Song Art Festival. Displays were exhibited at the Academy Library highlighting Provo City’s Sister Cities.

    Energy:

    • Maintenance of Existing Rates for 2003 - Rates were held at existing levels for the 15th consecutive year and retail rates maintained at below average for the state while high reliability and excellent customer service marks were achieved.
    • Receipt of National Award - The Community Service Award from the American Public Power Association was presented to Provo City Power for its community service in the 2002 Olympics held in Provo.
    • Achievement of One Million Hours of No Time Lost Accidents - An unprecedented milestone of no time lost accidents was reached by Provo Power employees from January 21, 1999, through November 22, 2003 (one million man hours).
    • Issuance of $21,530,000 in Energy System Revenue Refunding Bonds - A $1,662,000 net present value benefit was yielded through the refinancing of this energy system debt which was more than 7.5% of the refunded principal (greater than twice the customary 3% benchmark).  This will result in an annual savings for the remainder of the life of the bonds of approximately $120,000 per year up to the year 2014.
    • Sale of Geothermal Power Plant - The Provo-lead sale of the under-performing Cove Fort Geothermal Power Plant was achieved, allowing the department to retire approximately $8,000,000 in associated debt. Lower power costs and retired debt equal savings to Provo of nearly $1,500,000 per year for the next 10 years. Other members of UMPA benefitted with an equal percentage in power supply cost savings.
    • Successful Control of Inventory - Nearly $1,300,000 in inventory was successfully managed by the Warehouse Division with a year-end physical count variance of only $400 or total of approximately $2,000 for both physical count and cost variation adjustment. In addition, the overall inventory of approximately $1,400,000 was reduced by $175,000 or over 10%.
    • New Meter Reading Training - New written instructions and improved testing programs were developed for meter readers to maintain the quality and efficiency of the reads. The cost per read at $0.22 and accuracy of over 99% is a significant improvement over the last five years. Safety training on dog attacks continues to be a challenge, and more remote read meters are being installed.
    • Completion of New Transmission Power Line - A new 46 kV transmission line was completed through the middle of Provo, extending from 2230 North and 200 West to the Gillespie Substation near 5600 North Canyon Road. An agreement with Utah Power enabled the project to be completed and extensive public relations work facilitated the line to be built with minimal problems to the public.
    • Completion of New Distribution Power Line - A new main backbone 600 amp distribution line was completed from the Tanner Substation near 1700 South State, extending along Nevada Avenue to 700 South 1500 East. This new line will allow a full capacity backup for two circuits out of two different substations, substantially increasing the reliability.
    • Completion of New Distribution Substation - A new distribution substation will be completed by the end of the year at the relatively low cost of $450,000.  Existing equipment was used and located in the Tanner Substation to drastically cut the cost of the project.  This will increase the capacity of southeast Provo by 20 MW, providing power to the future Ironton development and backup to residents in southeast Provo.
    • New Street Lighting - Two blocks of decorative street lighting on University Avenue from 200 South to 300 South and from 200 North to 300 North were installed.  The new lights will improve the aesthetics of the downtown area and offer electrical outlets for holiday lighting.
    • Upgrading of Electrical System - The old, over-sized system in the Scenic Drive area which was purchased from UP&L many years ago was upgraded.  Poles were replaced and transformers moved from the interior yards to the streets for better accessibility during outages. Additional work is planned for the coming year.
    • Electrical Upgrade for New Medical Center - The existing overhead lines were converted to underground lines for the new 500 West Medical Center.  This required installing a new 600 amp underground power line and new service drops and removing all overhead lines.
    • New Development and Maintenance Electrical Jobs - A total of 225 work projects were completed by the engineering division and operation crews; including; new subdivisions, maintenance work, new street lights, distribution upgrade projects, pole relocations for street widening programs, etc.
    • Electrical Service for Utah County Health and Justice Building - An existing 4 kV power line and a 12 kV power line were removed and relocated, allowing the new health building to be constructed without delay.
    • Ongoing Tree Trimming and Conservation Efforts - A total of 7,807 trees conflicting with the power system were pruned by the Forestry Division, exceeding their annual goal and reducing the number of tree-related outages to 19 for the year. In addition, a total of 626 new trees were planted and another 1,115 given away as part of the energy conservation program.
    • Upgrading of Billing System Software - A major system upgrade to the customer information (billing) system was completed after three years to improve system performance and efficiency, enhance billing information to the customer service representatives, and add modules for future online payment options. In addition, the billing system became interoperable with the finance system, automating the transfer of utility revenue on a daily basis and eliminating manual intervention and process time.
    • Extension of Customer Service Hours - The hours for handling customer service inquiries dealing with utility billing or other city-related work have been successfully extended for over a year.  Calls continue to increase as more consumers become aware of the extended service hours. The help desk software continues to improve in order to deal with the variety of customer issues and to assign the work to appropriate departments.
    • Implementation of Maintenance Program at Substations - Testing, fixing, inspecting, and cleaning activities have been initiated at all twelve substations for the entire backbone of the system.  This enables the system to continue operating at peak capacity and provides for backup services in a emergency situations.
    • Continuation of Meter Maintenance and Replacement Programs - Testing, repairing, and replacement of hundreds of meters per year continue to be performed by the meter technicians to ensure accurate reads for the consumers. 645 new meters were added to the system this year. Developments in automated meter reading practices are being monitored and a variety of systems tested in pilot programs.
    • Status of Telecom Fiber-To-The-Home Demonstration Project - Video, data, and telephone services are being offered over fiber optics to 273 homes located in the Grandview area, providing an opportunity to prove the technology and understand the costs for deployment using a variety of construction methods and materials. Several cities and utilities have visited Provo to learn more of the FTTH technology.
    • Status of iProvo Telecom System - In addition to the FTTH demonstration project, the system is connected to approximately 500 apartment units and 15 businesses with services from a retail provider.  Provo is helping and benefitting from telecom connections to other non-Provo projects such as the Canyon Meadow development (60 units), the Parkway Crossing development (188 units), and data services to Spanish Fork and American Fork.
    • Community Outreach Activities - A monthly Mayor’s message and newsletter were circulated which provided reminders about energy conservation and safety. The Community Fair was held at Provo Towne Centre as part of the public power celebration, and special attention was given to key commercial accounts.

    Finance:

    • Restructuring of Department - The department was restructured, eliminating a management position, and the skills and abilities of each staff member better utilized to empower key staff members with more responsibility, making the reorganization successful.
    • Administration of Rental Dwelling Business License Policies & Procedures - Landlords were encouraged to fill out required information on the Internet, saving costs and preventing the need to hire additional staff. Landlords were also enabled to renew their annual business licenses online and make payments via the Intranet.
    • Establishment of Procedure for Computer Surplusing - A new policy and procedure to surplus outdated computers was established.
    • Organization and Administration of Cell Phones - The responsibility to organize and administer cell phones for all City departments was assumed by the department. Timely and accurate information will be provided to directors to facilitate better decision-making and allow for higher accountability of cell phone costs.
    • Increase in Usage of Procurement Card Program - Usage of the procurement card program, which streamlines the purchasing process and saves administrative costs for the City, increased by 183%.
    • Distribution of Documents on CD - The annual budget and Comprehensive Annual Financial Report were distributed on CD and made available on the Provo City web-site, saving on printing costs and increasing their usability.
    • Implementation of One-Stop Business Registration Program - A new one-stop business registration program was successfully initiated in cooperation with Salt Lake City, Sandy City, a number of state agencies, and the IRS to develop a system through which a new business owner can register with all necessary agencies at one time.
    • Reporting Under GASB34 Model - The GASB34 Reporting Model was used again this year for the City’s reporting. This is a major effort involving much of the Finance Department and Budget Office personnel’s time.
    • Certification from the Government Finance Officer’s Association - Certification from the GFOA was received for FY2002, the eleventh consecutive year this prestigious recognition has been given.

    Fire & Rescue:

    • New Training Outlines and Manuals - Training outlines were standardized and a new probationary manual for recruits created.
    • Restructuring of Duties - Several tasks from upper level management were reassigned to first line supervisors; including; staffing, Kronos/payroll tracking; calendaring/scheduling; and monthly summaries (business inspections, training activities, and shift duty logs).
    • New Paramedic Transport Ambulance - The specification, bidding, and purchasing processes were completed to place a new paramedic transport ambulance into service.
    • Upgrading of Cardiac Defibrillators - The cardiac defibrillators on all five paramedic rescue ambulances were upgraded to Lifepak 12 with capnography enhancement, enabling carbon dioxide to be measured in the respiratory tube to ensure correct placement in the patient’s windpipe.
    • Placement of Defibrillator at Eldred Center - An Automatic External Defibrillator was purchased and placed at the Provo Eldred Center, enabling the general staff to provide life-saving cardiac defibrillation to heart attack victims while awaiting the arrival of an ambulance.
    • Creation of Electronic Standard Operating Procedures - The SOPs for the Fire Department were made available in electronic format on the citywide F: drive.
    • Conservation/Cost Saving Efforts - The City’s Intranet was utilized to post policies, procedures, maintenance manuals, and other publications to reduce the usage of paper. Online purchasing was employed to facilitate direct procurement of items.
    • Preservation of Department Historical Records - Photos, news clippings, magazine pictures, and other items were electronically scanned for long-term preservation.  Efforts were initiated to update the department historical records which currently only cover from 1888 to 1959.
    • Completion of Paramedic Courses - Final paramedic courses for all shift members were completed.  Future hiring practices will require that the eight-month certification courses be completed prior to employment.
    • Funeral Services for Mario W. Guerrero - Funeral services for Provo City Paramedic Mario W. Guerrero who was killed in a Life Flight helicopter crash January 10 were organized and conducted.

    Human Resources:

    • Work Force Diversity Efforts - Greater focus was placed on workforce diversity by: improving the City’s Affirmative action plan, adding 150-plus targeted posting notifications, and providing dual language labor law posters throughout City buildings.
    • Conversion to 4-10 Work Weeks - The official conversion of all participating departments and employees to a 4-10 work week was accomplished, including the revision of 14 applicable personnel policies and procedures. Numerous inquiries from other agencies across the country who are interested in following Provo’s lead have been responded to.
    • Recapturing of Unemployment Costs - Close monitoring of ongoing unemployment claims throughout the year resulted in a recovery of $6,000 to-date in unqualified payments.
    • Reduction in Worker’s Compensation Claims - Through improved claims tracking and employee return-to-work efforts, plus new departmental safety program efforts, claims have dropped significantly, trending at a reduction of over $100,000 for the second year in a row.
    • Performance of Annual Compensation Market Study - An analysis comparing City compensation levels to the market was performed.  Findings were favorable with a few minor changes being recommended to the Administration.
    • Improvement in Risk Exposure - Safety, insurance, and risk control audits were performed throughout the City and a number of joint ventures.  Physical, procedural, and coverage improvements were made, resulting in reduced exposure for the City and associated agencies.  Aggressive business insurance negotiations were made which also resulted in below-market-average and budgeted rate increases.
    • Implementation of Nation’s First HRA for a Municipality - The nation’s first Health Reimbursement Arrangement for a municipality was implemented in January 2003. Employees who manage current healthcare employer dollars judiciously can carry unused funds forward for future and post-employment use.  The City was spotlighted in national publications and gave numerous presentations on this progressive approach to consumer-driven health care management.
    • Distribution of Health Care Benefits on DVD - A comprehensive overview of employee benefit options were provided to employees on a professionally-produced DVD to educate and assist them in the annual open enrollment process.  Provo City is the first municipality in the region to utilize this innovative approach to employee benefits education and was able to do so at no cost inasmuch as the entire funding was covered by benefit providers.
    • Upgrading of Computer System - A major upgrade to the Human Resource Management, Payroll, and Benefits software programs was achieved, converting the system to an Internet architecture. This was a significant effort by HR staff and will provide departments and employees with greater and more simplified access to desired information.
    • Increase in Application Form Processing - Over 200% more job application forms were received and processed in each of the past two years due to the increase in the nation’s unemployment rate.
    • New LTC Program - A new voluntary Long-term Care benefit program was made available to employees this year.
    • Evaluation of Position Refills - Each vacated position was carefully reviewed with departments to consider need, alternatives, and justification for refill.  Recommendations were then made to the City Administration.

    Information Systems:

    • Ongoing Service to Departments - Standard hardware and software configurations were implemented, purchasing procedures established, and almost 300 PC’s and laptops replaced.
    • New Data Center - A new data center consisting of 24 new servers, a Storage Area Network with 3 terabytes of capacity, and a new backup system with tape jukebox were installed.
    • New Unicenter Enterprise Management System - A new enterprise management system with Network and System Monitoring, Asset Management, and Software Deployment was installed.
    • Upgrading of Servers - The file and print servers were upgraded to Netware 6.0.
    • Upgrading of Groupwise - The Groupwise system was upgraded to version 6.5, and the first user training in recent times on this product was provided for City employees.
    • Upgrading of PeopleSoft Human Resource Information System - The PeopleSoft HRIS was upgraded to version 8.3, enabling employees to obtain answers to many HR and payroll questions directly from the PeopleSoft system. This was a major shift in technology from traditional client-server architecture to Web-based architecture and will allow new versions to be immediately distributed rather than requiring installation on individual PC’s. The upgrade was completed on schedule, without incident or disruption to payroll or other critical HR functions, and without the assistance of outside consultants, saving the City thousands of dollars.
    • Upgrading of Public Safety Backroom Infrastructure - An upgrade to the Public Safety backroom area was completed which included the replacement of servers, upgrade of the NetRMS report management system, installation and conversion of the existing Police CAD system, installation of a new firewall and router on the state WAN, and a new VPN solution for secure remote access to police records.
    • Upgrading of CDPD Systems - All CDPD systems in police vehicles were upgraded to GPRS for 5x increase in speed and improvements in coverage. This also included upgrading and enhancing the PSI software for patrol cards to allow near-realtime dispatch information and department-specific search capabilities.
    • Reorganization of Department - The department was reorganized to allow resources to be dedicated to the purchase, deployment, and support of desktop and laptop systems without increasing budget.
    • Upgrading of Utility Billing System - The utility billing system was successfully upgraded to Banner 3.0 which also required the upgrading of associated systems.
    • Integration of Business Licensing with Case File Program - Business licensing functions were integrated with the Community Development case file program which included a web-based application to accommodate Rental Dwelling Licensing.

    Legal:

    • Continuation of Efforts to Acquire Property - Efforts to acquire property for the 4800 North connector road between University Avenue and Canyon Road were continued.  The case was argued before the Utah Supreme Court with a result expected by Spring. In the alternative, support from the Utah County Commission for a condemnation by the county if the Supreme Court rules against Provo City’s condemnation was negotiated.
    • Use of Innovative Domestic Violence Prevention Measures - The prosecution of domestic violence was actively pursued by Provo City staff on a state-wide basis, bringing about an innovative approach to fighting this growing crime. The Deseret News reported, “Provo is the only city in the county to address the problem through domestic violence court.  The regular sessions help authorities track offenders in court-ordered counseling programs and ensure victims are protected.”
    • Court Ordering of Ignition Interlocks - Court-ordered ignition interlocks have been successfully obtained by prosecutors in certain DUI cases (second or more offense; blood alcohol above 0.16) which should lead to the reduction of DUI-related accidents.
    • Dismissal of Claims for Future Earnings - In a civil rights suit where liability against the city had already been determined, a dismissal of the claims for future earnings was achieved. This was substantial inasmuch as the plaintiff had sought between $11,000,000 and $20,000,000. The plaintiff was ordered to pay the City’s attorney’s fees associated with this portion of the case.

    Library:

     Administration:

    • Feliz NavideZa Celebration - Feliz NavideZa, a true Hispanic Christmas celebration of many Spanish cultures, was organized and presented with tremendous success–approximately 3,500 were in attendance.
    • Reorganization of Administrative Functions - Administrative functions were reorganized to allow for full time effort to secure additional funds through fund raising and grant development.
    • Election of Director to Association Presidency - The Library Director, Gene Nelson, was elected Utah Library Association President.
    • Public Speaking Engagements - Director Nelson spoke to various civic and church groups.

      Children’s Services:

    • Sponsoring of Programs - Over 800 programs were sponsored during the last year with over 70,000 in attendance.
    • Appointing of Division Manager to Committee - The Children’s Services Manager, Carla Morris, was appointed to the Randolph Caldecott Committee, which is responsible to award the annual Caldecott Medal for Children’s Literature.
    • Participation in Literacy Pilot Project - An emergent literacy pilot project sponsored by the Public Library Association was participated in by Provo City as one of 11 libraries throughout the country.  These efforts were recognized in American Libraries and The School Library Journal.
    • Public Speaking Engagements - Director Gene Nelson and Manager Carla Morris spoke at the national Public Library Association’s Spring Symposium.
    • Status of Annual Summer Reading Program - A record high of 4,201 participants was reached for this year’s annual summer reading program. Over $305,000 of “in-kind” donations were contributed by the business community.

     Adult Services:

    • Ongoing Public Service Activities - Approximately 130,000 queries from the public were fielded during the last year.
    • Service to Slate Canyon Youth Detention Center - Library service to the Slate Canyon Youth Detention Center was established.
    • Expansion of Spanish Collection - Materials for the Spanish collection were increased, and the area for collection was expanded.
    • Reclassification of Collection - The reclassification of the nonfiction LDS collection was completed.
    • Sponsoring of Adult and Teen Summer Reading Program - The 2nd Annual Adult and Teen Summer Reading Program was sponsored with over 1,050 participants.
    • Ongoing Programs - Approximately 221 programs were presented this past year with over 3,000 attendees. Fifty-nine of the programs were presented in Spanish.

     Support Services:

    • High Level of Circulation - A high level of circulation was maintained at approximately 100,000 per month.
    • Increase in Collection - An additional 25,311 items were added to the collection.

     Information Systems:

    • Upgrading of System - A major upgrade of the Horizon (Dynix) system was completed.
    • New Wireless Network - A wireless network for patron laptops was installed.
    • Reconfiguration of Library Network - The library network was configured to allow the training lab to connect directly to the City network for utilization in training exercises.

     Events:

    • Ongoing Events - Approximately 1,200 events were facilitated.  These ranged from weddings, reunions, high school proms, and graduations to business lunches, film festivals, lectures, and support groups.
    • Status of Rental Fees - Total rental fees of $115,313 were received.
    • Sponsoring of First LiterArtcy Event - The first Provo City Library LiterArtcy Gallery competition and show was sponsored.
    • Obtainment of Sculpture - The Avard Fairbanks sculpture of Brigham Young was secured.

    Parks & Recreation:

    • Adjustment in Organizational Structure - The structure of the park maintenance division was reorganized to promote accountability, improve efficiency, and conserve water.
    • Completion of New Park - The Indian Road Trailhead Park was completed and grand opening ceremonies held as a part of National Trails Day.
    • Development of Park Safety Action Plan - An action plan to address safety issues at Wilderness Park was developed, and low brush and trees were cleared out to improve visibility.
    • Acquisition of Foothill Park - Foothill Park was acquired through a private donation of 65 acres of property.  Public access to the park trail system was created.
    • Sesquicentennial Commemoration - The Cemetery Sesquicentennial Commemoration was planned and organized in conjunction with Memorial Day.  A decorative fence and entrance arch were installed around the perimeter of the Cemetery.
    • Acquisition of Property for Cemetery - Four acres of property to the west of the Cemetery were obtained for future expansion.
    • Development of Web Page - A web page for the Provo City Cemetery was developed for the convenience of patrons.
    • Completion of City Property Projects - Several construction projects on City property were completed; including the following: physical improvements to the City Gym;  remodel of Eldred Senior Center office; remodel of Police Department training room; repair of flooding areas at City Center; and acceptance of janitorial bids.
    • Improvements in Employee Safety Program - A more aggressive safety education program was implemented, and a safety incentive program was initiated.
    • Completion of Feasibility Study for New Arts Center - A feasibility study was completed for the new Arts Center in the old library building. The fund raising phase has commenced with focus on construction funding.
    • Creation of New Recreation Programs - New programs were offered by the Recreation Division with no impact to current budgetary guidelines.  These included: a park movie series, Start Smart sports programs for preschoolers, Monday Nights Live concert series, weekend softball tournaments, and additional citywide special events.
    • Involvement in Special Events - Winterfest and First Night were again handled by the Recreation Division as liaison with citizen leadership. Many new activities and improvements were added to enhance the events.
    • Initiation of New Field Rental System - A refined field rental system for group use of sports facilities was implemented by the Sports staff.  Fees generated will be used to assist in field maintenance and field improvements; including; dug out covers, cooling misters, and drinking fountains.
    • Activities of The Center - Many community programming partnerships were created to allow groups such as country dancing, family counseling, sports, scouting, and others to utilize The Center as their venue. A new skate park and improved game room facilities are being developed to meet user requests and to make The Center the facility of choice.  Students are now being transported to The Center from school to eliminate the hurdles associated with participation in programs.  Grants are being obtained for scholarship registration costs for underprivileged youth.

    Police:

    • Remodel of Training/Conference Room Area - The training/conference room area was remodeled into a “state-of-the-art” training facility. It also provides four new offices for victim advocates and public relations personnel as well as a much needed conference room.  The training area and conference room are available for the use of others.
    • New DARE Car - A detective division vehicle was converted into a DARE car equal to any in the state with the help of local businesses who donated paint, wheels, tires, lighting, and decal work.
    • Continuation of Grant - In addition to the $791,000 that has been received in the previous five years, a Department of Justice grant for $390,000 was continued for two years which goes to the Victim Assistance Program, Child Victim Assistant, two Children’s Counselors, and a full-time and part-time Public Relations Specialist.
    • Charging of Robert Allen Kartchner - Through the teamwork of the Provo City Police force, Robert Allen Kartchner, who has been charged with the kidnaping of a child in Mapleton, Utah, was charged with kidnaping and attempted kidnaping.  The stalking case of another child was also solved.
    • Development of New Public Information Videos - Two new videos–Faces of Domestic Violence and Provo Emergency Preparedness–were created, providing meaningful insight to Provo residents on these important subjects.
    • Arrest of Burglary Suspects - Several individuals involved in burglaries throughout Utah County were arrested during the month of November through the combined efforts of CID, Patrol, and COP.  This resulted in the recovery of thousands of dollars worth of stolen property.
    • Conversion to New Crisnet System - The Dispatch Center’s and Records Division’s computer systems were successfully converted to the new Crisnet computer system. The existing computer-aided dispatch system, which had been in place for 15 years, had become archaic and unable to integrate with newer programs and technologies currently in use.  Through the efforts of IS, records/dispatch personnel, and MEGG associates, the system was obtained at a substantial savings.

    Public Works:

     Engineering:

    • ITS (Intelligent Transportation System) Efforts - All traffic signal systems citywide were connected via fiber optics cable.  Traffic signals were timed and coordinated.  Eight downtown CCTV cameras, video detection, and Impath communication equipment for 14 intersections were installed.  A contract for a Traffic Operations Center was obtained and the initial installation completed.
    • Work on Traffic Signals - Seven location traffic signal projects, including six locations along 200 West and 1230 North and 700 East 700 North were completed.  Two new traffic signals were installed at 4400 North University Avenue and 450 North 900 East. Traffic signals were upgraded at 900 North Campus Drive which included connection to the traffic system. Traffic signal detection equipment was rebuilt along the 1230 North corridor, the 2230 North corridor, and Canyon Road in conjunction with the installation of storm drains and the water main upgrade project.  Traffic signal knock down repair work was completed at 900 East Birch Lane and 1860 South Novell Place.  Traffic signal cabinets were replaced at 500 West Center Street, 300 South University Avenue, and 1230 North 500 West.
    • Special Improvement District 103 Activities - Improvements along 1100 West, including storm drain and sidewalk upgrades, were installed. Street improvements along 600 South, including storm drains, and along 1600 West, including the intersection realignment at 1600 West and 600 South, were made.
    • Status of Street Overlay Program - The following streets were included in the program for this past fiscal year: 2200 North from Canyon Road to Stadium Lane, 900 East from Center Street to State Street, 200 West from 920 South to 300 South, 600 South from 200 West to 100 East, and West Center Street from Geneva Road to 3100 West.  In conjunction with this project, several bike lanes were installed at 2200 North, 200 West, 900 East, 600 South, and Center Street.
    • Completion of College Connector Trail - A connector trail was completed along University Parkway, 900 East, Temple View Drive, and 2300 North which included the installation of sidewalk improvements along the north side of University Parkway opposite the Marriott Center.
    • Completion of Various Studies - A pavement management study was completed during which an inventory of all streets were provided in coordination with Samsung for the GASB 34 requirements and all city streets were inventoried and condition assessments completed.  A geologic hazards study was completed in the Sherwood Hills area. Several studies of a proposed Traffic Impact Fee were completed to look at assessing new developments for proposed impact on the transportation system within the City.
    • Street Widening Projects - The project to widen 820 North, 1375 West to Independence Avenue, included the installation of a new traffic roundabout at the intersection of 820 North and 1375 West. The project to widen 920 South Street from 200 West to 500 West is underway.  Property owners have been contacted to secure rights-of-way and install improvements to help minimize the cost to the City.  A storm drain from approximately 200 West to 400 West was also installed. The street along 600 South from 200 West to 100 East was widened to provide better access to businesses in that area. 200 North Street, approximately 1200 West near Action Target, was widened which included acquiring a right-of-way as well as installing improvements along a portion of the street. 
    • Installation of Right-Turn Pocket - A right-turn pocket was installed for east bound to south bound traffic at Columbia Lane and 500 West and the signal re-timed to include a right-turn overlap for west bound traffic.
    • Reconfiguration of Intersections - The intersection at 4500 North University Avenue, which has historically been a high accident area, was modified, and, in coordination with the neighborhood, access to the Northgate neighborhood was reconfigured through the new signal at 4400 North University Avenue. The intersection at 1460 North Jordan Avenue was reconfigured, including the installation of left-turn lanes to increase safety and provide better access to the school.
    • Status of Provo Harbor Bridge on Center Street Project - Construction on this project will begin once the design is completed which is currently underway.  The necessary environmental approvals have been obtained.
    • Installation of Interactive Control Message Sign - An ICM sign was installed to help alert drivers to speed violations along Foothill Drive.

     Public Services:

    • New Air Traffic Control Tower - Funding for construction of an air traffic control tower was secured and site prep-construction has commenced.  Construction of the actual tower should be out for bid by the end of the year.  Two important issues associated with the project were resolved; namely, lowering the tower height below the transition surface area and having the FAA commit $450,000 to upgrade to a Doppler VOR.
    • Implementation of Right Hand Pattern - A right hand pattern was implemented for runway 13/31 which was a critical step in the master plan and in constructing an air traffic control tower.
    • Completion of Airport Construction Project - The North Apron Rehabilitation Project was completed which included realignment of FBO tie-downs and completion of the North Taxiway.
    • Installation of “No Outlet” Signs and Pedestrian Crosswalks - All Dead End signs were replaced with the new “No Outlet” signs and pedestrian crosswalk flag stations at six highly-trafficked pedestrian crosswalks were installed.
    • Status of Sidewalk Maintenance Program - Sidewalk replacement efforts have exceeded any performed in the previous year including many in the CDGB area. All outstanding requests for the City/Property Owner shared program have been completed.
    • Status of Crack Sealing Program - One-third more square feet of roads were sealed this year, equaling over seven times greater than totals from two years prior.
    • Implementation of Curbside Recycling - An agreement was made with Waste Management to begin a subscription curbside recycling program. There are currently 1,647 residents participating.
    • Compost Yard Activities - Revenue in compost yard operations was nearly $10,000 more than last year.  The number of residents in the yard waste program increased by 275 for a total of 2,297 residents.
    • Implementation of New Fleet Management System - The fleet management system was upgraded from Peregrin’s Fleet Anywhere to CFA Fleet Management software. The new program is more user friendly and will save over $5,000 in annual maintenance costs.
    • Achievement of Surplus in Fleet Management Budget - The fiscal year was ended with a $69,000 surplus in the Fleet Management budget, a significant improvement over the past trend of going over budget.

     Storm Water:

    • Completion of Diversion Channel - Construction of the debris diversion at the mouth of Buckley Draw below the burn area was completed in late July, safely diverting future mud flows and preventing damage and cleanup efforts for homes and neighborhoods.
    • Herding and Removal of Carp - Thousands of carp were “herded” downstream to avoid the need for their extermination.  In addition, approximately 15,000 carp were removed from this area in coordination with the UDWR, avoiding a possible ecological and environmental disaster.
    • Construction of Storm Drains - A 30" - 54" storm drain was constructed along Freedom Boulevard between 920 South and 400 South and along 600 South between Freedom Boulevard and 400 West, marking the completion of the second phase of the project to significantly improve storm drainage in the city south of 800 North. In addition, an 18" - 27" storm drain was constructed along 1100 West between 1400 South and 600 South and along 600 South between 1220 West and 1100 West in coordination with SID #103.
    • Response to Upper East Union Canal Piping - As a result of the piping of the private irrigation canal, new storm drains were designed and constructed along 2230 North (Canyon Road to Provo River), Birch Lane/1200 East (Ash Avenue to 820 North), and Nevada Avenue/900 South (1000 South to 1150 East).
    • Pursuit of NPDES Storm Water Quality Permit - In compliance with new Federal regulations, a Notice of Intent was submitted to the State Division of Water Quality in March.  Ongoing efforts are being made to work with the State and other communities to comply with these regulations in a cost effective manner.
    • Status of SCADA Project - Remote monitoring and control of the five most critical storm water pumping stations in the City is being achieved by this project.  This will enable more effective operation of these stations and more timely response to problems.
    • Completion of Major Maintenance Projects - In coordination with the Parks Division, the Cemetery parking lot was reconstructed to improve drainage conditions. Several small projects were completed in Ironton with the Economic Development Department to improve surface drainage and to monitor ground water movement. Several small drainage projects were also completed in response to the piping of the UEU Canal.
    • Mapping of Storm Drain System - Approximately 25% of the City’s storm drain system was incorporated into the City’s GIS mapping system.
    • Completion of Impact Fee Study - An updated analysis was completed which documented the need and justification for adjusting the storm water impact fee.